DesignVerdictBeta
← Back to rapporteurs

Board of Appeal rapporteur

A. González Fernández

Decision-lead on 5 Board of Appeal cases · 20252026.

Decisions

5

Appeals dismissed

3

Appeals upheld

0

Reversal rate

0%

This rapporteur overturns first-instance decisions 0% of the time on substantive appeals, versus a Board-wide average of 24.4% 24.4pp more likely to affirm.

This rapporteur
0%

Dotted line = 24.4% Board average. Based on 3 substantive appeals.

Outcome mix

Appeal dismissed
3
Invalidated (total)
2

Caseload mix

Invalidity appeals
5
Other appeals
0
Restitutio in integrum
0
CDR (pre-2025)
5
EUDR (from 2025)
0

Most-seen grounds

  • Article 25(1)(b)5
  • Article 6(1)3
  • Article 7(1)3
  • Article 42
  • Article 72
  • Article 3(a)1

Recent decisions led

DateCaseAppellantOutcome
2026-02-26R0849/2025-3holderAppeal dismissed
2025-11-14R0519/2025-3holderAppeal dismissed
2025-11-14R0518/2025-3holderAppeal dismissed
2025-04-01R0370/2022-3applicantInvalidated (total)
2025-03-13R0370/2022-3applicantInvalidated (total)